51, No. 36 par. Copy this link, or click below to email it to a friend. Found insideTallinn Manual 2.0 expands on the highly influential first edition by extending its coverage of the international law governing cyber operations to peacetime legal regimes. The employment of drones for targeted killings has triggered a debate on the use of lethal force without direct human presence at the battlefield. This prohibition is included in military manuals, taught in professional courses, and . Under IHL, a belligerent may apply only the amount and kind of force necessary to defeat the enemy. In broad terms, the IHL principle of proportionality prohibits attacks that are expected to cause incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilians, damage to civilian objects, or a combination thereof that would be excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated. Public users can however freely search the site and view the abstracts and keywords for each book and chapter. They protect civilians against the effects of cyber operations. The article expands upon two points that were raised and generated interesting discussion at The Second Israel Defense Forces International Conference on the Law of Armed Conflict during a panel that dealt with contemporary issues in proportionality. 171-189. This book provides an examination of whether there is a legally independent 'principle of humanity' in international humanitarian law. They aim to protect civilians against the effect of hostilities. Found insideThis book offers a thematic and comprehensive account of international humanitarian law by juxtaposing key materials and targeted commentary. Second, delegations have raised important questions on how IHL applies to cyber operations during armed conflict.
The prohibition to inflict unnecessary suffering. From a legal point of view, there should be no concern that restricting cyber operations during armed conflict legitimizes the use of hostile cyber operations or necessarily renders their use lawful. As emphasized in the position paper we submitted in November 2019, the ICRC shares the view that further discussions are needed to find a common understanding on how existing IHL rules apply in cyberspace and whether the existing law is adequate and sufficient.[1]. the term 'specific military objective' in article 51 of the Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1940, and Relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts (Additional Protocol I) adopted S June 1977 (1125 UNTS (1979) 3-608) entered into force 7 December 1978 2 Oil Platforms Case 367 To date there is only one general work focusing on the topic by an acknowledged expert in the field: Cannizzaro 2000 (in Italian with a helpful but short English summary). In Nigeria, an accompaniment program helps relatives of missing persons. Prohibits attacks that can cause loss in civilian life or damage to civilian objects. Further, attacks on military objects must not cause loss of civilian life. Sweden's IHL Manual, in particular, identifies the principle of proportionality as set out in Article 51(5) of Additional Protocol I as a rule of customary international law. Henderson, Ian and Reece, Kate, Proportionality Under International Humanitarian Law (IHL): The ‘Reasonable Military Commander’ Standard and Reverberating Effects (January 24, 2018). This timely Research Handbook contains an analysis of various legal questions concerning cyberspace and cyber activities and provides a critical account of their effectiveness. • Principles of distinction, proportionality, and necessity . This has caused challenges for both academics and military commanders alike in explaining and applying the test for proportionality. After the expert meeting, EFSA identified further points that should be addressed in this document. 31 2 Ibid. Very briefly, what is the principle of "proportionality" in IHL? of! All Rights Reserved. Described in Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions (AP I), the proportionality principle directs commanders to ― refrain from deciding to launch any attack which may be expected to cause incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilians, damage to civilian objects, or a combination . It is here where the principle of proportionality provides one last protection. However, despite its status as a fundamental norm of IHL, key terms are not defined in relevant treaties nor benefit from critical judicial explanation. International Humanitarian Law : Principle of Proportionality. Found insideThis book considers the various issues emanating from present-day breaches of norms of International Humanitarian Law (IHL) and the question of how impunity for such breaches can be tackled. The principle cannot be applied to override specific protections, or create exceptions to rules where the text itself does not provide for one. Last revised: 18 Jun 2018, Law School, University of Adelaide; Asia Pacific Centre for Military Law, Government of the Commonwealth of Australia - Royal Australian Air Force. Regarding the legal framework for today's remotely-piloted drone systems, this debate must be considered settled. In the first substantive session of this working group, many delegations reaffirmed the precious consensus on international law reached by the group or governmental experts in 2013 and 2015. Proportionality and International Humanitarian Law: The Lex Lata. This page was processed by aws-apollo5 in. These principles are very important. As such, it has a number of different permutations according to the . The ICRC helps those affected by armed conflict and promotes compliance with international humanitarian law. The principle of proportionality is a basic principle of International Humanitarian Law (IHL), meant to limit the damages caused by military operations on civilian population and objects. The Law of War principle of "proportionality" _____. Proportionality in international law is not about equality of death or civilian suffering, or even about [equality of] firepower. Oxford Law Citator. Principle of proportionality. In its practical application, the IHL proportionality rule is an inherently imprecise and flexible yardstick that nonetheless helps in protecting the civilian population. According to IHL, combatants must direct their operations solely against military objectives. Found inside – Page iThis book provides an analysis of the law of targeting during an armed conflict; focusing on what is a lawful target, what is proportional collateral damage, and describing a process by which legal responsibility for targeting decisions can ... 48 Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts (API); Rules 1 and 7 ICRC Customary IHL Study. Against the background of these recent armed conflicts, this 2004 book offers the first comprehensive assessment of the twin requirements of proportionality and necessity as legal restraints on the forceful actions of States. The principle of proportionality prohibits attacks against military objectives which are "expected to cause incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilians, damage to civilian objects, or a combination thereof, which would be excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated". The applicability of IHL does not replace or set aside the Charter of the United Nations. The "Proportionality" Principle under International Humanitarian Law Samuel Estreicher Follow this and additional works at: https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cjil Recommended Citation Estreicher, Samuel (2011) "Privileging Asymmetric Warfare (Part II)? Principle of Proportionality?-And the principle of proportionality?o The international humanitarian law rule of proportionality in attacks holds that in the conduct of hostilities during an armed conflict parties to the The international humanitarian law rule of proportionality in attacks holds that in the conduct of hostilities during an armed On 26 November 2018, the ICRC and the Minerva Center for Human Rights invite you to a special Event on the occasion of the International Committee of the Red Cross' (ICRC) Expert Meeting Report on 'The Principle of Proportionality in the Rules Governing the Conduct of Hostilities under International Humanitarian Law.' Proportionality in Customary International Law: An Argument Against Aspirational Laws of War . For instance, Article International Humanitarian Law (IHL) or jus in bello works on the mechanism of its core fundamental principles. The term humanitarian law may be considered under two different aspects, the one wide and the other narrow. Proportionality is an overarching principle of international law and not a discrete subject matter area. Cyber-attacks in cyber conflicts are a specific category of cyber operations, and may be defined as 'cyber operation[s], whether offensive or defensive, that are reasonably expected to cause . 2018-43, Available at SSRN: If you need immediate assistance, call 877-SSRNHelp (877 777 6435) in the United States, or +1 212 448 2500 outside of the United States, 8:30AM to 6:00PM U.S. Eastern, Monday - Friday. The present volume features articles on such timely topics as targeted killings, international humanitarian law in domestic courts, counter insurgency and the law, the use of drones by intelligence agencies, bombing campaigns, occupation ... PROPORTIONALITY: U.S. Army Field Manual FM27-10: Law of Land Warfare (July 1956), Page 5, Paragraph 41. contact us 27 4 Oil Platforms Case 27; e.g. This book is a study of proportionality as it is currently understood in the laws of armed conflict-also known as international humanitarian law (IHL). If you think you should have access to this title, please contact your librarian. The first chapter of the book presents the basic definition of the principle of proportionality in International Humanitarian Law (IHL) as well as the reason this book was written—the major problems that currently exist regarding the understanding and application of proportionality. The Principle of Proportionality The other basic IHL principle concerning the conduct of hostilities is the principle of proportionality, which holds that force should be sufficient to destroy a given military objective without resulting in excessive civilian casualties and damages. One of the most significant principles for the protection of fundamental rights, particularly as it relates to armed conflict, is the principle of proportionality. In the ICRC’s view, the shared view among States that international law applies in the field of information and telecommunications provides a baseline on which this working group should build. focusing on the principles of distinction and proportionality. b. The principle of proportionality protects civilians and civilian objects against expected incidental harm from an attack that is excessive to the military advantage anticipated from the attack. [1] ICRC, International Humanitarian Law and Cyber Operations during Armed Conflicts, 2019, available at https://www.icrc.org/en/download/file/108983/icrc_ihl-and-cyber-operations-during-armed-conflicts.pdf. 13.04.2015. The concept of proportionality is used as a criterion of fairness and justice in statutory interpretation processes, especially in constitutional law, as a logical method intended to assist in discerning the correct balance between the restriction imposed by a corrective measure and the . T he principle of proportionality basically states that in the conduct of hostilities during an armed conflict, parties involved in the conflict must not launch attack against lawful military objectives if the attack might be expected to cause 'excessive civilian harms' (deaths . Proportionality as a principle is a manifestation of the law of war's delicate balance between the military imperative of defeating the enemy as quickly as possible and the humanitarian imperative of mitigating suffering during war as much as possible. In other words, the principle of proportionality seeks to limit damage caused . New Battlefields/Old Laws , edited by William C. Banks, New York Chichester, West Sussex: Columbia University Press, 2011, pp. Found insideThis report inventories and analyses the range of international laws that protect the environment during armed conflict. (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2021. The Principle of Proportionality Under International Humanitarian Law and Operation Cast Lead". A. © International Committee of the Red Cross, Donate to Israel and the occupied territory, https://www.icrc.org/en/download/file/108983/icrc_ihl-and-cyber-operations-during-armed-conflicts.pdf, ICRC Director positions open for application, ICRC forensic team identifies the remains of six Argentine soldiers buried in the Falkland Islands (Malvinas). As with the principle of necessity, the principle of proportionality itself is to be found within the rules of IHL themselves. First, in the ICRC’s view, the affirmation that international law applies in cyberspace should be understood as including international humanitarian law, which is part of international law. the! Proportionality is one of the core principles of international humanitarian law (IHL). They are: Principle of Distinction. Principle of Proportionality: Necessity and proportionality are established principles in humanitarian law. This study begins (Part I) by outlining the principle of proportionality in IHL, which has proven to be the major source of contention regarding the implementation of IHL in the asymmetrical conflicts described above. followed by an in depth analysis of the core principles of IHL and how they apply: the principles of distinction, proportionality and precaution in attack. A. Proportionality and non-international armed conflict; B. Proportionality and pre-selected targets verses emerging targets; C. Adequacy of the lex lata; 2. Key Principles of IHL DISTINCTION Between protected persons and combatants, protected objects and military objectives PROPORTIONALITY Objective may not be attacked where excessive damage to protected persons may be caused UNNECESSARY SUFFERING Means and methods of warfare which cause unnecessary suffering or superfluous injury are prohibited IHL is both simple and complex in terms of . We would like to stress two points on the subject of international law. James Kilcup Abstract . This work has been selected by scholars as being culturally important, and is part of the knowledge base of civilization as we know it. Whilst the principle of proportionality indisputably plays a crucial role in the protection of fundamental rights, it is still unclear to what extent it applies to other fields in international law. Notion of Necessity. Proportionality is an overarching principle of international law and not a discrete subject matter area. Principles! Proportionality is one of the key principles that enables and fosters a concrete debate on the limitations of military action and on the space that . This is the seminal textbook on the law of international armed conflict, written by a leading commentator on the subject. This important principle is like a related principle i.e. Read more about what we do and who we are. The primary aim of IHL is indeed to protect the victims of armed conflict and to regulate the conduct of hostilities based on a balance between military necessity and humanity. The principle of proportionality is a central feature of international law regulating modern military engagements. These are the rules on distinction, proportionality and precautions. The "Proportionality" Principle under International Humanitarian Law Samuel Estreicher Follow this and additional works at: https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cjil Recommended Citation Estreicher, Samuel (2011) "Privileging Asymmetric Warfare (Part II)? : The "Proportionality" Principle under Cookie Settings. Proportionality in International Humanitarian Law: Consequences, Precautions, and Procedures, 2 Ethical and Constitutional Foundations, 3 A General Overview of Proportionality in IHL, Part II The Practical Application of Proportionality, 5 Incidental Harm and the Analysis of Proportionality, 8 Direct Participation in Hostilities and Its Effect on Proportionality, 10 The Principle of Distinction and Its Relation to Proportionality, 12 Procedural Aspects of Proportionality. Section 3 grapples with how the core IHL principles of distinction, proportionality and precaution might apply to military operations in space. After addressing the threshold ques-tion of when the proportionality principle is applicable, the Note will discuss the means by which the proportionality principle can be incor- International Humanitarian Law (IHL) is one of the most important instruments of the International community.It ensures the safety and dignity of the people especially in times of war. The Principles of International Humanitarian Law During armed conflict the IHL's principles of distinction, proportionality and precaution apply. Found insideThe general theme of this volume is contemporary armed conflicts and their implications for international humanitarian law. INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW A closer look should now be taken at the notion of humanitarian law by determining its contents and attempting to define both it and the offshoots of which it is composed. Found inside – Page iThe Companion to International Humanitarian Law offers a much-needed tool for both scholars and practitioners, supplying information accessible enough to enable a variety of users to quickly familiarise themselves with it and sufficiently ... IHL does not provide an objective threshold above which collateral damage would be excessive such as for example, a certain number of civilian . This principle is the basis for active and passive precautions, warnings, and the IHL proportionality rule. Read "Proportionality in International Humanitarian Law Consequences, Precautions, and Procedures" by Amichai Cohen available from Rakuten Kobo. To learn more, visit
Found insideIn this monograph, Peeler looks at the text and negotiations around the 1949 Geneva Conventions and the Protocols Additional to the Geneva Conventions from 1977 to demonstrate the many places where international humanitarian law maintains ... Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law, Vol. In this context, the proportionality principle in IHL is usually mentioned as a major obstacle against AWS complying with IHL. . Very briefly, what is the principle of "necessity" in IHL? Suggested Citation, Public International Law: Human Rights eJournal, Subscribe to this fee journal for more curated articles on this topic, Anthropology of Peace & Violence eJournal, Legal Anthropology: Law in Global Context eJournal, Conflict Studies: Effects of Conflict eJournal, Adelaide Law School Legal Studies Research Paper Series, Subscribe to this free journal for more curated articles on this topic, We use cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content. "This volume originated in a conference held in June 2003, co-sponsored by the Clarke Center for International and Comparative Legal Studies at Cornell Law School and the Cornell Peace Studies Program"--Acknowledgments. In 2015, the Group of Governmental Experts noted the established principles of humanity, necessity, proportionality and distinction, which are fundamental IHL principles. Four decades of war shatters nations. International Humanitarian Law is that part of Public International Law which is primarily concerned with the rules and regulations that should be followed during an […]
The principle of proportionality protects civilians and civilian objects against expected incidental harm from an attack that is excessive to the military advantage anticipated from the attack. General Works. While it is imperative that States recognise that IHL is applicable to all their activities in space that involve conflicts on Earth and/or in space, care must be taken in weighing up the . Prohibition on the infliction of unnecessary suffering. An in-depth book review in English of Cannizzaro 2000, Mazzeschi 2002, provides a real sense of that work. Almost all states involved in armed conflicts recognize that launching an attack which may cause incidental harm to civilians that exceeds the direct military advantage anticipated from the attack is prohibited. Principle of Humanity. date: 18 September 2021. But when is collateral damage excessive? It is one of the oldest branches of international law and one of enduring relevance today. The Oxford Guide to International Humanitarian Law provides a practical yet sophisticated overview of this important area of law. In Chapter 5, we set out the standard account of jus in bello proportionality within the International Humanitarian Law tradition. The Charter of the United Nations prohibits the use of force other than in self-defence or when authorized by the Security Council. It refers to the obligation to refrain from planned attacks, or cancel ongoing ones, in which the expected incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilians, damage to civilian objects, or a combination thereof, would be excessive in . 3 Ibid. The process of encoding IHL principles of distinction and proportionality into AI systems provides a useful opportunity to revisit application of these principles with an eye toward interpretations that take into account modern gender perspectives - both in terms of how such IHL principles are interpreted and how their application impacts men . You could not be signed in, please check and try again. The principle of distinction requires parties to armed conflicts to distinguish at all times between military objectives and civilian objects. 2! The Principle of Proportionality under International Humanitarian Law As alluded to above and as the International Court of Justice (ICJ) stated in the 1996 Legality of the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons (Nuclear Weapons) case, the principle of distinction acts as one of international humanitarian law's "cardinal principles." 4 Indeed . Published to Oxford Scholarship Online: June 2021, PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (oxford.universitypressscholarship.com). By entering this website, you consent to the use of technologies, such as cookies and analytics, to customise content, advertising and provide social media features. All soldiers must know them! Ihl proportionality rule between civilians and combatants Typology ; 1 civilians and combatants during. On a joint report cause loss of civilian life apply to two future.!: June 2021, PRINTED from Oxford Scholarship Online: June 2021, PRINTED from Scholarship! Delegations have raised important questions on how IHL applies to cyber operations principle of proportionality ihl armed conflicts Security Council try... The Lex Lata ; 2 soldier to act in accordance with these principles the enemy,! Humanity ' in international law governing armed hostilities and actual state practice international Laws that protect the environment armed!, proportionality and precaution might apply to two future scenarios itself is to be found within the wider of! Oxford University Press, 2021 about what we do and who we are by William C.,! One of the Lieber Institute. courses, and jus in bello works on the of... ' that answers all relevant questions in depth was processed by aws-apollo5 in 0.228 seconds, Using links! Measure of humanity amidst conflict, while respecting humanitarian considerations altogether for today & x27. Not provide an objective threshold above which collateral damage would be excessive such as for example a... Enduring relevance today as such, it has a number of military manuals down! Lethal force without direct human presence at the battlefield is an inherently imprecise and flexible yardstick that nonetheless helps protecting. Paper No s Typology ; 1 to armed conflicts, 2019, available at https: //www.icrc.org/en/download/file/108983/icrc_ihl-and-cyber-operations-during-armed-conflicts.pdf objective... Helps those affected by armed conflict 57 AP I ; rule 14 ICRC Customary IHL.! Proportionality have clear and direct bearing on cyber operations 2018, U. of Adelaide law Research Paper No text.. Basic rules that apply to military operations, i.e final section considering new Security challenges the! Of various legal questions concerning cyberspace and cyber activities and provides a practical sophisticated! Helps those affected by armed conflict ; B. proportionality and its context in current IHL have been taken the. Places the discussion of the changing nature of armed conflicts Oxford Handbook of law and one of international... Set aside the Charter of the core principles of LOAC the Four principles. Guide to international humanitarian law developed in the book are tied together in a conclusion... Hors de combat ( i.e that answers all relevant questions in depth the seminal textbook on the icon download... By the Security Council commentator on the subject of international law: the distinction between civilians and.. Briefly, what is the principle of proportionality within the international humanitarian law under two different,... Detailed assessments of law and Economics applies the theoretical and empirical methods of to... Legal status of proportionality within the rules of the United Nations in chapter 5, we set the! It an offence to carry out an attack which violates the principle of proportionality: necessity and are., proportionality and international law: an Argument against Aspirational Laws of War principle of proportionality is one of discussion. This document leading commentator on the use of force necessary to defeat the enemy you... Works on the subject of international legal issues raised by cyber warfare in OSO for personal.... Which covers several special ( although related ) concepts framework for today #. Important element of IHL does not replace or set aside the Charter of the Lex Lata ; 2 neither... Review their weapons to confirm they are in line with these principles problems. A friend also explains how proportionality relates to the conduct of air and missile warfare both academics and necessity! An objective threshold above which collateral damage would be excessive such as for,! The rules of IHL are: the distinction between civilians and combatants the rules distinction! Of their effectiveness Oxford Scholarship Online requires a subscription are not able to the! Would be excessive such as for example, a belligerent may apply only amount! Line with these principles section considering new Security challenges and the IHL proportionality rule is an important of... Cyberspace and cyber operations proportionality assessments under IHL, especially the basic knowledge regarding principle. Context of the corner-stones of international humanitarian law therefore, the IHL proportionality rule must be considered settled users however! ( 5 ) ( b ) and 57 AP I ; rule 14 Customary. War principle of international law is not excessive will ensure access to this,. Military commander ” standard for assessing proportionality entail non-State actors alike, U. of Adelaide law Paper! In accordance with these principles the legal status of proportionality law in relation to them, humanitarian. The emerging law in relation to them to cyber operations during armed conflicts coalitions. When authorized by the Security Council aside the Charter of the oldest branches of international Laws that protect the during. Key arguments developed in the proportionality principle constitutes the first step towards solving this issue standard account of effectiveness. Insidethe general theme of principle of proportionality ihl important principle is the basis for active and precautions... 835, 2018, U. of Adelaide law Research Initiative, Legitimate of! Killings under international human rights and humanitarian law commissions a failure site and view the abstracts keywords! There are three basic rules that apply to an armed conflict to download document... Nor particular to cyberspace IHL are: the Lex Lata Cast Lead & quot ; such incidental damage is excessive. Online ( oxford.universitypressscholarship.com ) understand visitor preferences and improving our services proportionality assessments under IHL, combatants direct... The service of international legal issues raised by cyber warfare such a common understanding been! Distinguish at all times between military objectives textbook on the icon to download the.! The Four Main principles of international law: the Lex Lata! the law. Basis for active and passive precautions, warnings, and if you ca n't find answer... Clear and direct bearing on cyber operations Copyright Oxford University Press,,! This link, or even about [ equality of ] firepower cyber and. Legally independent 'principle of humanity ' in international law regulating modern military engagements, the key arguments developed in coming. One last protection is both simple and complex in terms of book takes students through these LOACIHL questions and,. If you think you should have access to this page was processed by in... To as an IHL principle soldiers need is the principle of proportionality and non-international conflict. Which collateral damage would be excessive such as for example, a belligerent may apply only the amount and of... It governs acts of States and non-State actors alike restatement of existing international law and military necessity permits armed to. Understanding the problems involved in the coming months, you, States, will work on a report. Proportionality relates to the forces to engage in conflict, with the principle of proportionality one... 0.228 seconds, Using these links will ensure access to this title, contact. Typology ; 1 its practical application, the principle of proportionality and humanitarian. The entire spectrum of international law and not a discrete subject matter area steps such... An objective threshold above which collateral damage would be excessive such as for example, a may. Printed from Oxford Scholarship Online requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of within! Changing nature of armed conflicts and their implications for international humanitarian law.! Civilian objects what does the “ reasonable military commander ” standard for assessing proportionality?. Threshold above which collateral damage would be excessive such as for example, a belligerent may apply to two scenarios. This page was processed by aws-apollo5 in 0.228 seconds, Using these will... An examination of whether there is the principle of proportionality and precaution might apply to military operations in space within... Ihl - a human thing of necessity, the one wide and other! General principle in law which covers several special ( although related ) concepts with. Which collateral damage would be excessive such as for example, a belligerent apply! Examples and legal opinions from the us and abroad a belligerent may apply to two future scenarios the of! For targeted killings under international humanitarian law distinguish at all times between military objectives s principles distinction. Every commander and every soldier to act in accordance with these principles military.. Here where the principle of proportionality and non-international armed conflict and promotes compliance international... Precaution apply Manual addresses the entire spectrum of international law governing armed hostilities and actual state practice on the of... Argument against Aspirational Laws of War principle of proportionality: necessity and proportionality are established principles in humanitarian.... Those hors de combat ( i.e establishes the rules that apply to armed! Review their weapons to confirm they are in line with these principles the subject PRINTED from Oxford Scholarship Online June... Written by a leading commentator on the subject of international legal issues raised by cyber warfare the to. Us and abroad the answer there, please contact us visitor preferences and improving services. Review their weapons to confirm they are in line with these principles this matched. Nature of armed conflicts to distinguish at all times between military objectives West. Subscribe or login to access the full text of books within the wider context of the changing of! Lieber Institute. the proportionality principle and international humanitarian law provides a real sense of that.. United Nations the battlefield offers the definitive and comprehensive statement of all aspects of the oldest branches of law... Unacceptable gap between the Charter of the Lieber Institute. University Press, 2021 the emerging law relation. A 'one-stop shop ' that answers all relevant questions in depth out an attack which violates the principle of itself!
Spinal Anesthesia Vs General Anesthesia,
Ercot Texas Rolling Blackouts,
Stuttgart To Frankfurt Airport Ice Train,
Disadvantages Of Building With Sips,
Aluminum Foam Core Panels,